This is an incredible setting, and I could wake up every day to the view from the porch! But, some attention is needed in the kitchen to address the basics, and a remodel would put this place on a solid 5* across the board.
I also have a bit of an issue with not knowing that the owner was going to be remodeling the adjacent home. The noise was fairly well governed, but on two days kept us from enjoying the property. There is room for much better communication or perhaps some accommodation by the owner during the construction.